Sub Stop

Discover delicious pizzas, cheesesteaks, burgers, shakes, and more at Sub Stop Pizza in New Oxford, PA. Enjoy great prices, friendly service, and tasty bites in a welcoming local spot.

Welcome to Sub Stop

Taste the Difference.

Sub Stop
Sub Stop
Sub Stop
Sub Stop

Located at 228 Lincoln Way E, New Oxford, PA 17350, Sub Stop serves a delicious array of classic American eats. This pizza restaurant combines local warmth with a menu that delights any craving. Whether it's your first visit or a regular outing, Sub Stop embraces every patron like family. From cheesesteaks to pizza burgers and everything in between, the menu reflects the town's love for hearty, satisfying meals.

The atmosphere buzzes with energy, especially during peak hours like Saturday afternoons.

Prices are wallet-friendly, making it a go-to spot for families, teenagers, and anyone looking for a quick, tasty bite. With friendly service always at the forefront, you’ll feel right at home.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

228 Lincoln Way E, New Oxford, PA 17350, United States

Phone

+1 717-624-3221

Social Media

About

The Culinary Story

Sub Stop
Sub Stop
Sub Stop
Sub Stop

Sub Stop offers a delightful culinary experience rooted in classic American flavors. The establishment has evolved over time, becoming a staple in the New Oxford community. As a beloved pizza restaurant, it caters to diverse tastes with an extensive menu designed to satisfy every appetite. With highlights like their cheesesteak, cheeseburger, and unique pizza burger, diners frequently return for the comforting flavors.

The menu features an impressive selection of sandwiches, which include not only cold cuts and hamburgers but also Bar-B-Que options.

Sides like potato chips and a variety of fries complement any meal and enhance the dining experience. The dedication to quality ingredients shines through each dish, reflecting the restaurant's strong commitment to delivering mouthwatering meals.

Beyond the food, the vibe in Sub Stop captures the spirit of New Oxford. Regular patrons often share stories and laughter, creating a welcoming environment for newcomers and returning guests alike.

Community connection thrives within these walls, with locals gathering to share meals and memories. The restaurant is not just a place to eat; it's a hub for friends and families, serving dishes that nourish both body and soul. As the local appetite grows, Sub Stop remains committed to evolving and innovating its menu while preserving its roots as a cherished community destination.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • SundayClosed
  • Monday11 AM-7 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-7 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-7 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-7 PM
  • Friday11 AM-7 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-7 PM

Sub Stop has become more than just a place to grab a meal; it's a local hangout spot where flavor meets community. With 68 menu items to choose from, diners relish a variety of options, including sandwiches, sides, and unique creations like the pizza burger and walking taco.

Patrons rave about the cheeseburgers and shakes, highlighting the commitment to quality ingredients and robust flavors in every dish.

The restaurant is especially popular on Saturdays, often reaching full capacity by 1 PM. For those seeking a quieter experience, Wednesday evenings present a perfect opportunity to enjoy fantastic food without the crowd. The combination of great prices and excellent service makes Sub Stop a favorite among New Oxford locals.

Sub Stop

Sub Stop boasts a classic diner feel, inviting visitors with a cheerful exterior filled with bright signage that hints at the deliciousness inside. The outdoor seating creates a relaxed environment, where patrons can enjoy their meals while soaking in the local atmosphere. The vibe is casual and friendly, reflecting the town's small community charm.

As you walk in, the warm greeting from staff sets the tone for an enjoyable dining experience.

This welcoming approach resonates with local traditions, making you feel like a part of the New Oxford community.

The decor features timeless Americana, with cozy booths perfect for families or friends gathering to share a meal.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

The food is great! We have had their Cheeseburger subs and there Fish subs. Very delicious along with fries which are also very good! Always very friendly!

S
Stan W.

I have been going to Sub Stop since I was in high school (over 25 years ago lol) they've always been amazing! Great food. Great staff. Great atmosphere. If you want a "hometown spot", this is it! I was there the other day and was taken back to my high school days when I saw that they still take good care of the Colonials football team! It was awesome! I will ALWAYS be a patron to Sub Stop!! Love you guys!! Oh, and if you have little ones, I highly recommend the hot dog! My 2 year old granddaughter LOVES to come here for hot dogs!

C
Carissa C.

Always love to come here. The ladies are the greatest and treat us like family. This is our daughter Sophia's favorite place to go.

C
Chris K.

Super fresh and the "softest melt in your mouth" sub roll ever !!! Fantastic sandwich and wonderful polite ladies running the operation !

M
Mark M.

What a hidden gem! Family owned business with attention to high quality, locally produced ingredients. I had the walking tacos, and was blown away by the quality and flavor! Beef was from a local bucher, and the seasoning made my taste buds dance. This is a must-go place!

Z
Zach K.

I broke down next to Sub-stop, but what I found wasn't just a bite to eat. It was warmth, kindness, and one of the best subs I've ever had. They didn't just serve food; they offered help, a smile, and a space that felt like a hug. Unexpected moments make the best memories. I'll be back! Not just for the sub, but for the soul of this place

G
Gwendal M.